"The definitive look at the original series hadn’t been written – until now. An exhaustive, episode-by-episode history."
- JEFF BOND, Geek Magazine |
"Trek fans will die and get beamed up to heaven!"
- BILLY HELLER, New York Post |
“Entertaining and informative in more ways than there are stars in the cosmos.”
– KEVIN LAUDERDALE, Author Magazine. |
"I can assure you that this will be one of those books that in years to come is reverred as one of the ultimate reference guides to Star Trek."
- CLIVE BURRELL, Some Kind of Star Trek |
"This is going to be the bible to Star Trek and how it was made.
This is a book that I'm going to keep near and dear and utilize throughout my life."
- ROD RODDENBERRY (son of Gene Roddenberry).
This is a book that I'm going to keep near and dear and utilize throughout my life."
- ROD RODDENBERRY (son of Gene Roddenberry).
"In 580 pages Cushman tells the story of Season One, episode by episode, and it's a compelling read for the Star Trek aficionado as well as anyone interested in television history." - CHRIS GARDNER, stuff.com.nz Read the full review. |
"Puts any other book [on Star Trek] to shame - including my own"
- DAVID GERROLD (TOS writer of "The Trouble with Tribbles") |
"Amazing! Believe the hype; this IS the TOS Bible!"
- WILL SMITH, TOSGraphics.com
- WILL SMITH, TOSGraphics.com
"Will be applauded by Star Trek fans and researchers for decades!"
- GERALD GURIAN, startrekpropauthority.com
- GERALD GURIAN, startrekpropauthority.com
"A bargain at ten times the set price. Detailed beyond anything I've ever seen"
- CURTIS FOX, startrekpeople.com
- CURTIS FOX, startrekpeople.com
Amazon Readers give it 5.0 out of 5 STARS!
★★★★★
Amazon Reviews Are Original and Unedited
★★★★★
Finally history never knew about the tv series!,
posted December 1, 2013 By Michael D. Heintz (Seattle, WA USA)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
In depth, thorough! New stuff, never read. Great rare pics! Amazing history and info. detailed well above and beyond other books before.
★★★★★
For Real Fans!,
posted November 23, 2013 By Stephen W. Gordon (West Valley CIty, Utah United States)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Great for the real fan. Goes into deep detail. On some scripts it gives a daily, blow by blow story of how the plot came about.
★★★★★
Wow! Fantastic book...well organized...a must have!!,
posted November 19, 2013By Alan (LaVergne, TN, United States)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Just when you think that there is nothing new to be learned about Star Trek...Surprise! This book is a wonderful read and a treasure trove for Trekkies! Lots of good information about television production back in the day. I can't wait for the follow ups for Season Two and Season Three as well!
★★★★★
Great Read, wonderful Insight....,
posted November 14, 2013 By Victor
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Got the book and It's fab... The wealth of information Gene Roddenberry and his crew retained during the filming is incredible... It is amazing that Marc Cushman was able to befriend Gene and obtain the documents to developed the true behind the scenes of Trek Original Series... Cannot wait for the Next two Installments.
★★★★★
FIVE STARS: It doesn't get any better than this!,
posted November 10, 2013 By AlwaysReading "Lane" (California)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
It doesn't get any better than this. It's a years-in-the-making book -- detailed (but not boringly so), well researched, well-sourced (quotes by the episode directors, Star Trek cast, guest actors, the scriptwriters, producers, etc.), and it is written in a style that is intelligent and entertaining. It's fun 'pick-me-up' reading and a fantastic behind-the-scenes look into the making of the first season episodes of the original series. This book and "Inside Star Trek: The Real Story" by Herbert Solow and Robert Justman will be the best two books about the original series that a Star Trek fan will ever want to read. Here's hoping that a promised Season Two book (based on the inner pages, it seems like there will be one) is published soon. Highly recommend.
★★★★★
Well Researched, Highly Readable - FANTASTIC!,
posted November 9, 2013 By A. Holland
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Not since Stephen E. Whitfield's "Making of Star Trek" have a read a book so thorough on the creation of the original Star Trek series. And thorough in different ways - it is a tremendous effort and a great work. I highly recommend this for anyone who wants to understand the nuts, bolts, and creative choices made for TOS.
★★★★★
One of the best books ever written about a TV show,
posted November 3, 2013 By Lee Goldberg (Los Angeles, CA USA)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
After nearly fifty years, I thought there wasn't anything more to be said, or any more books that could possibly be mined, from the original Star Trek. Hasn't that show been talked about, and examined to death, down to every last detail?
You'd think so. But then along came These Are The Voyages: Season One by Marc Cushman and it may be the best book yet about the production of the series and one of the best books ever written about any TV show. It's a shame the book is presented as yet another fan-written curio for the diehard trekker...because it's a must-read for students of television, and aspiring TV writers, regardless of whether they watched, or liked, Star Trek.
These Are The Voyages is an exhaustively detailed look at the writing and nuts-and-bolts production of every single episode, from the first, failed pilot onward. Everything in the book, like a TV series, starts with the scripts...and Cushman walks us through every draft and every change, whether they were prompted by creative issues, budgetary concerns, production issues, or network notes.
The author relies on extensive interviews with the show's surviving writers, producers, directors, and actors (and archival interviews with those who have passed away) and never-before-released memos, budgets, shooting schedules, and other internal documents. Best of all, Cushman manages to remain, with only a few slips, remarkably objective and scholarly about his subject, leaving the book refreshingly free of the kind of cringe-inducing, fannish drool that usually typifies books about "cult" shows and Star Trek in particular.
These Are the Voyages is a treasure trove of information and a fascinating look at how a TV show is written and produced...and all of the forces that shape it. I'm eagerly looking forward to the next two volumes.
★★★★★
Beam This Up,
posted October 30, 2013 By Mark Twain (Virginia, USA)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
This is a MUST read for Star Trek fans, It's also a great look at the early days of television on the west coast. Marc is a terrific author who has really done his research. I personally have some ties to some of the people mentioned in this book and find it very insightful. This is a great read!
★★★★★
great reading!,
posted October 28, 2013 By Joseph H Hoch JR - See all my reviews
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
A "must have" for any Star Trek fan. Marc Cushman sure did his research! Can't wait to read next two books.
★★★★★
What a revelation!,
posted October 21, 2013 By Kevin Black
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Blazing through the galaxy of Star Trek reference books comes the new gold standard. These Are the Voyages: TOS Season One by Marc Cushman is massive tome that looks like a textbook. Here it is by the numbers: 541 oversize pages of text, original interviews with 65 people important to the first season of Star Trek, including Gene Rodenberry, Robert Justman, Dorothy Fontana, James Doohan, and Grace Lee Whitney, an 11-page bibliography of books, newspaper & magazine articles, and a 15-page index of quotations. All this, and it only covers Season One!
All the secondary research is supplementary to the real heart of this book: Cushman gained access to the original series archives, safeguarded through the years by Justman and Roddenberry, and now in the custody of the UCLA Performing Arts Library. These include endless production memos and letters between writers, producers, and technical craftspeople and consultants which reveal the real story of Star Trek as it evolved on the fly from early 1964 to mid 1967. This is the kind of book that's only possible as a labor of love, 26 years in the making (Cushman wrote the treatment for the third-season Next Generation episode "Sarek," and his interviews with Rodenberry in contemplation of this writing date back to 1982 and 1990).
A work this dense may sound intimidating. Amazingly, it's compulsively readable. The 100 pages or so describing Roddenberry's background, the development of Star Trek, and the struggles to cast the show, film two pilots, and achieve a first season order read like a page-turning potboiler, informed on every page by Cushman's deep knowledge of and infectious enthusiasm for television history.
Nor does the book lose pace when it dives, one at a time, into the making of Star Trek's 29 first season episodes. Here Cushman spices things up by placing the episodes in historical context with cultural tidbits about other shows on television, songs on the radio, and moments in history. He does not forbear to offer his own careful, informative critical appraisal of each episode. The value these comments bring do not depend on the unassailability of his judgment--I disagree that episode 1.17, "Shore Leave," belongs in "the stratosphere of TOS's very best" (I think it's the worst first season episode)--but Cushman's description of its theme still caused me to reevaluate and increase my appreciation: "Dreams and nightmares sleep side by side, so be careful what you think about while on a world where wishes do come true." (Page 366.)
To read this book is to constantly learn new tidbits about and explode myths regarding favorite episodes. His interviews about the filming with guest stars both prominent and obscure add color. Did you know that episode 1.13, "The Conscience of the King," started out as a Holocaust story, with Kodos as a "Hitlerian" figure who "almost conquered the Earth?" Or that the writing staff, who hated the name Klingon, asked Gene Coon, producer and writer of episode 1.27, "Errand of Mercy," what planet Klingons came from, and he laughed and said "Kling?" Cushman also publishes for the first time the Neilson ratings for each episode, showing that Star Trek was much more popular coming out of the gate than we have always been led to believe.
While the tidbits are fun, the greatest value of These Are the Voyages is in peeling back the curtain on the creative process. How does a show as original as Star Trek get made? What makes it difficult? What were the real contributions of the people behind the scenes? Why did the staff have so much trouble with storied science fiction writers? (Cushman also includes a list of storylines that underwent development, but were never completed or produced.)
What I found most fascinating was to watch the hand of Roddenberry himself, whose reputation has suffered somewhat following questions about the quality of his contributions to The Next Generation. Cushman gives us the letters, memos and facts necessary to fully appraise his contribution as Star Trek's creator, best friend and undeniable animating spirit, but also its worst enemy at times when his combative personality strained ties with network executives, outside writers, and even his own staff. Yet when you see his mark on especially the first ten episodes, you see him repeatedly acting to make the show better, often dramatically so, no matter the personal cost. Even after Roddenberry took a step back midseason, the staff couldn't help but continue to follow his example. In Cushman's words: "As proven again and again by the documents preserved in the series' files stored at UCLA, the Star Trek creative staff was obsessively driven to make every script - every episode - as good as they could possibly be, within the limits, of time, budget and censorship." (Page 254.)
Regarding the production of These Are the Voyages itself, there are flaws in the copy editing, which only make me want to volunteer my time to help make volumes two and three the best they can be. With a book this good, the only serious criticism I can make is that it is too short. I want more of everything. More production memos! More interviews! More, bigger photographs, and in color! Hundreds more pages! This is work that could just keep going. If the universe is kind, Cushman's achievement will provide an inspiration to others.
★★★★★
top drawer,
posted October 14, 2013 By Charlie Schmidt
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
This is the best writing on Star Trek TOS ever. It is absolutely fascinating to learn of the behind the scenes production issues, script drafting and revisions, personality conflicts, killer deadline schedules. This book is worth every penny and is MUST HAVE for any person who loves TOS. Mr. Cushman, you can put me down for Volumes 2 and 3. Wow, wow, and wow.
★★★★★
I FEEL I AM THERE ALL OVER AGAIN!!!,
posted October 13, 2013 By Leslie Parrish (Seattle)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
As one of the guest stars on the original Star Trek series, (I was the Goddess in “Who Mourns for Adonais”) I’ve been thrilled and amazed reading this brilliant, detailed reconstruction of the creation of this ground-breaking series!
I feel I am there all over again ― on the Desilu lot with the visionary Gene Roddenberry and his associates ― and the great stars of TOS, who became dear friends.
Marc Cushman’s research, which I know took six years of intensive work, takes us behind-the-scenes to see what went into this series ― information than even those of us who were there never imagined!
This is the book that everyone who loves Star Trek, with its awesome insights into the future ― inventions which are present in our lives today! ― will love!!! It sweeps us up in the massive effort it took to create this unique series so filled with vision, hope, brilliance ― and longevity!
Marc Cushman deserves credit and thanks from all who read this spectacular and authoritative work!!!
★★★★★
This is The Book on Star Trek TOS,
posted September 23, 2013 By kevin vasconcelos
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I have been a fan of the show since it first aired and after reading all of the books related to the series production of this and all that came after. I would have to say this was the most satisfying of all. I thought the Herb Solow and Bob Justman book was great and put me back in the 60's mindset and helping to set the record straight-well this will be a great addition for any fan of the series. Producing a television show like Star Trek at that time was an almost impossible feat. Reading this book shows what it took to make television/cultural history.I cannot wait unit TOS Season 2 is released.
★★★★★
Truth, Myths and Spin Are All Revealed,
posted September 21, 2013 By B. W. Bordelon "Bryan" (Kenner, Louisiana United States)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I am an original 1966 NBC broadcast Trekker who was 12 in its premiere and I have read everything published on the history of this iconic show, and while books some seemed to put you there in its creation, none has given me the feeling of fully understanding its birth. What this show did in 1966-69 was truly ground-breaking. Creative from the ground up, Star Trek boldly went where no other series has ever gone before. I cannot wait till the last two issues are published. This, along with the original series music soundtracks re-engineered and released on cd is Trek-Nirvana!
★★★★★
It is about time!,
posted September 11, 2013 By Dennis L (Evergreen Park, IL)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
It is more than just "about time" It is way past time that somebody finally gave us the entire story on this break-through series. What is even more fantastic is the detailed bibliography where one can find additional info on the series. It is too bad that the author missed one of the most important articles written about Star Trek, namely the one that was in the February, 1968 issue of Analog entitled "To Make A Star Trek". Now, I am anticipating next volume.
★★★★★
I didn't want to put it down!,
posted September 9, 2013 By Mark Thomas Passmore (St. Petersburg, FL USA)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Quite possibly the most informative book I've ever read on the original Star Trek series. Yet it has an easy style that makes one feel you were there as the events proceed. I can't wait for the next two volumes.
★★★★★
Thoroughly engaging as a Trek history read,
posted September 6, 2013 By PiperDE
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
As someone who is interested in the early history of Star Trek as a television series, Marc Cushman's book is thoroughly engaging. As a read, I find it most comparable to Inside Star Trek: The Real Story (by Herbert F. Solow and Robert H. Justman) which was 458 pages and covers a lot of "I was there" details. This book is 600 pages, weighs 2.6 pounds and there is two more coming. The amount of brand new, as well as well known information compiled from things that occurred almost 50 years ago can, at times feel overwhelming if you want to absorb every detail on every page. A lot of it is from research of original documents at UCLA. It's comprehensive and it shows. Then he adds in interviews that he did personally over the last 20 years from the main cast, directors, producers, extras and it seems anyone involved in the show. Cushman also goes on to reference a library of other biographies, autobiographies and vast stores of written knowledge. Another thing that really sets this book apart from others is a seemingly endless collection of behind the scenes photographs provided by Gerald Gurian as well as others from personal collections. This is not a book that you can sit down and read in a day. It is also a book you can pick up again and again as a reference for every episode of the first season when they were still trying to figure out how to put a difficult and expensive show on the air. I have watched my TOS blu-rays several times, but reading this adds to the experience by pointing out the extras, one episode actors, who they were, how they were cast, why they left, and information about them that had been unknown to me about their involvement before, during and after the show. He breaks down the cost of each episode, the writer, who did the re-writing, production issues, and touches on those great personal stories at every turn. It's like a fascinating college text book written by a professor you would want to keep talking to and follow down the hall even after class is over. It's entertaining to read and keeps you coming back for more early, sometimes obscure (the best kind) Trek knowledge. And there is a very complete easy to use reference at the end. As I mentioned before; there are two more of these coming that will each contain several more pages of 60's early Star Trek history. Favorite quote so far: "if the ring goes, Kelley goes."
★★★★★
Must read for TOS enthusiasts,
posted August 27, 2013 By Bret Lonsway
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
As a companion to the immortal "The Making of Star Trek" (which, by the way, NEEDS to be reissued as a high quality hardcover!), this is the definitive source on the creation, production and airing of the first season of the original Star Trek series and how it changed television forever. The saga of how ex-pilot/cop Gene Roddenberry and team convinced Lucy and Desi Arnaz to back their effort at a high-quality, adult science fiction series different from anything ever done is extraordinary and relevant to today's fragmented media landscape. It is also so good to see producer Gene Coon getting the credit he is due for really shepherding the continuity and "canon" of the Trek universe!
As Captain Kirk once said, "Risk is our business".
★★★★★
Boldly going where no behind-the-scenes books has gone before...,
posted August 25, 2013 By Christopher E.
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
A very impressive undertaking - One of the most detailed evaluations of the filming of a television series that I have seen. There have been many books discussing the filming of Star Trek, but never to this detail. With the release of long buried background material, this series has the potential to be the ultimate bible of Star Trek production. There are interviews with cast and crew, and a lot of information I never knew about the production. Great stuff.
Hard to believe this 600+ page book focuses on just one season of the original series, but it is well worth the read. Mark Cushman and Susan Osborn have their facts together and know how to make it interesting for the non-fan. For the fan, it is an absolute must. I look forward to getting the next volume covering Season 2.
★★★★★
A Must Have!,
posted August 25, 2013 By Eric Comptis
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
These are the Voyages is a must have for anyone interested in how and why this series was created. How did Gene develop the story, How was it presented to the networks, How was the director and writers picked. How was the cast picked and what were their original thoughts about the series. All these questions are answered and alot more.
This is a great book for Trekers and anyone interested in TV history. I loved it!
★★★★★
This Is Paradise,
posted August 23, 2013 By Scott (Edinburgh, Scotland United Kingdom)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
An astounding triumph for Marc Cushman. This is easily the best book on the original (and best) incarnation of Star Trek. Each episode of season one is given a detailed account of its production which includes fascinating memos and exchanges between the writers, producers, directors and actors. There is also an assessment about the strengths and weaknesses of each story. Cushman's judgement is pretty sound and I can't wait for volumes 2 and 3.
★★★★★
WOW! Best Trek Book - EVER!,
posted August 19, 2013 By Rick A
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Have you ever wished you were 'a fly on the wall' during the creation and making of the original Star Trek? Well, consider author Marc Cushman your genie and his book your wish granted.
There have been tombs of material written on the subject of Trek. From 'The Making of.. to 'The Real Story,' but NONE have captured the 'lightning in the bottle' like 'These Are The Voyages.' Every one of The original seven have put pen to paper and added their voice to the legend that is Trek, but they are coming from an actor's point of view. Those books are great reads, but they fail in comparison to what, I feel, is this 'tour de force' by author Marc Cushman. Not only does his book take you deeper than any other book but, as you read this page-turner, you'll feel like you're right there as the decisions are being made.
I was blown away by the huge amount of newly released information that you can only find in this book. New interviews with people in front of and behind the camera, memos, ratings and detailed drill downs on each and every episode of season one.
This book is a Trekkie's/Trekker's dream!
Finally, one of the most iconic shows in TV history has the first chapter in what will become an iconic trilogy of books.
All I can say is -- start making room on your bookshelf because two more volumes are on the way!
★★★★★
The Book I Have Always Wanted,
posted August 18, 2013 By LSpil (Missouri, United States)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I have hundreds of books devoted to the series and this has already become the most important one.
I have always believed that the Roddenberry papers at UCLA would make the basis for a significant contribution to the study of the show. Mr. Cushman's extensive original interviews and secondary research obviously added a great deal to the book, but his analysis of the memos and script drafts are what set this volume in its own class. Short of reading every memo and draft myself (maybe someday...), this book is the only means of determining how each episode moved from imagination to final cut, and who contributed what in each case. To illustrate the evolution of each show, and of the series itself, Cushman has incorporated original interviews and other quotations from critical (and often underrepresented) contributors to the show. Besides the crucial interviews with Gene Roddenberry, D.C. Fontana, and Bob Justman, Cushman quotes interviews with Steven Carabatsos, Gene Coon and many more. No examination of the birth of Star Trek could be complete without the participation of associate producer and script editor John D.F. Black, and Cushman has included detailed and newly shared recollections from Black and his wife Mary, who also worked on the series. Of course, the episodes speak for themselves and their artistic impact doesn't depend on understanding the means of their creation, but once a viewer decides to look at the next level--why the episodes say what they say--this work becomes a critical part of that discussion.
The book is all the more impressive for what it is not. Cushman includes all the dates, numbers, and dollar amounts that are required, but never sacrifices the narrative to those figures. Each episode is a story of production, and the details only help make the story more vivid. He is, as Dr. McCoy might phrase it, a writer, not an accountant. As a result, the book serves in two ways. I have used it as a reference source for individual questions, but it was also an absolute page-turner, which I read straight through. The refreshing thing about the book is how even-handed it is. When primary sources and participant interviews are used, such accounts can easily become hagiographies for or screeds against individuals. I would be shocked if any of the participants or their families could find any point in the book that was less than totally fair and supported. Cushman is also scrupulous about making his opinions clearly distinct from the research. This kind of analysis doesn't preclude opinion; on the contrary, it adds to the discussion. But he never blurs the line between what he has learned and what he thinks, and as a reader, I appreciate that care very much.
★★★★★
The Real Story of Star Trek,
posted August 17, 2013 By Thomas Jensen (Fairfield, CA, US) - See all my reviews
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I've known of some of Gene Roddenberry's credits, but not in the detail the author supplies on almost any fact known about the man. The first chapter alone is exceedingly interesting. I really enjoyed reading about his relationship with Erle Stanley Gardner for example. This book has captured the overall feel of the business, with the development of the networks, the working of television at the time and how Roddenberry found his place in it. Mr. Cushman's opening chapter on the man is revealing and extensive. The opening chapter is one where the curious can get up to speed on the man's life and how it started in an entertaining manner. The personal comments from the actors and those involved are priceless.
The book is quite revealing; I can't believe I'll get to read two more books on each season. Frankly, I'm not surprised that this book is good, but it's just so darn readable that I'm actually finding a new found love for the material. I have all of the books pertaining to the original show and I've found this one provides information I never knew about the series.
You get to read the memos from Gene Roddenberry, Bob Justman, et. all and there are new quotes from actors and writers who were there. It really does take you back to the time when it was all coming together and the amount of creativity involved in the undertaking.
Did you know Gene Roddenberry held studio screenings of episodes to potential writers for the show? Do you know why the Vulcan mind meld was created? The level of detail is impressive. I'd doubt that any other television show could be documented as this one has been here.
The interplay between the people who came together to create this unique and special series is great reading. Any student of television should read this book. Every episode has 20 pages of interesting tales that were never told. Comments from the studio mailbag are included after each episode chapter. Even the Neilson ratings are included. That's a first anywhere. Star Trek a failed show because of the ratings? The facts will surprise on just how well watched the original Star Trek was during its original broadcast run.
I'm feeling lucky to have this book. It's the first book since those from the 90's by the various people associated with the show, that has anything approaching new information that I'd want to know. And this book is physically a large book. I thank Jacobs/Brown for that, too.
I'm so happy this undertaking is not just by a professional who's in the business, but from a fan of Star Trek. A truly special volume for fans of the show.
★★★★★
OMG, Star Trek was NOT a network failure!,
posted August 16, 2013 By Scott Mcintyre "ssosmcin" (Long Island, NY)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I've had this book for 6 hours and I've finally put it down, but I'm nowhere near done reading. I thought I'd read and heard it all, but Mr. Cushman has truly done an amazing job giving us the real "Real Story" by focusing primarily on production and network documentation. He explodes myths that have dogged the series for decades. The information in the book is simply astounding. I'm learning so much new information and some of it is shocking. Like the ratings.
According to the information unearthed here, Star Trek was NOT a ratings failure when it first aired. In fact, the premiere was HUGE; the first episode alone captured 47% of the viewing public! It remained in the top 40 throughout it's first season and often won it's time slot. It easily beat many shows always believed more successful, such as Batman, The Fugitive, Lost in Space and others (it's immediate contemporary - The Time Tunnel - was 20 positions lower than Trek). Why it was considered a candidate for cancellation isn't touched upon until the second volume, but my guess is that it was because the series was a ridiculously expensive series for the cash strapped Desilu studios to produce and they were in way over their heads. So the whole "Star Trek was a flop" thing was BS. It may have lost viewers later, but during its freshman season, it was indeed doing well.
Of course, no Trek book is perfect and I did notice a couple of minor errors: observations about music between City on the Edge of Forever and Operation Annihilate were swapped for example (thanks to the LaLa Land Complete Series Soundtrack Box set we know what episodes had what composed for them). But for the most part, this is an exhaustive reference. I'll probably come back and add more to this as I read one, but I know my rating won't change.
Fantastic, essential book for fans and TV historians!
You don't think you'll lean anything new? Think again.
★★★★★
Fantastic- at long last,
posted August 16, 2013 By paustin Amazon Verified Purchase
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
This book has been a long time coming. A great book based on years of research and interviews and more importantly based on the archive given to the UCLA Performing Arts Library by Gene Roddenerry & Robert Justman shortly after the series ended. A true snapshot in time unaltered by failing memories. Papers written during the blood, sweet and tears of the making of the shows themselves. Filled with fantastic and rare behind the scenes photographs. I cannot wait until the next volumes come out. If you love Star Trek and are fascinated with behind the scenes tales of these beloved episodes "the classic 79" then this is for you...you owe it to yourself to pick this up. You will not regret it.
★★★★★
Fabulous,
posted August 13, 2013 By Howard A. Jones "Howard A. Jones"
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
A fantastic look behind-the-scenes of my favorite show, with all the details I never knew I wanted to learn about how the series was filmed, created, scored, and written. The insights into how and why various choices were made is eye-opening. For instance, in the script and even in the props for "A Taste of Armageddon" it was clear that Anan 7 was using some kind of instrument to alter his voice when he contacts the Enterprise, but because of the way the director shot the scene Anan 7 seems like a fantastic mimic.
Other reviewers have already said it -- I can't wait for the next volume. And I will read the third, as well, although a detailed analysis of why the third season was so bad is apt to be even more depressing than the season itself.
★★★★★
It's a Treasure!,
posted August 12, 2013 By Mariam True
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
If you think you know everything about Star Trek, TOS, think again! "These Are the Voyages" is the definitive book on the making of the original series. The author, Marc Cushman, provides stunningly-detailed descriptions of all elements of production for each episode (in the order they were filmed) with many great behind-the-scenes photos. Significantly, the author also includes the Nielsen ratings for each episode proving that Star Trek won its time slot week after week. The book not only provides information about series production but also gives the reader insights into the making of television in the 1960s. I thoroughly enjoyed reading about Gene Roddenberry's writing career, the involvement of Desilu Productions (gotta love Lucy), the designing of the show, and the two pilots. I can't wait for the next two volumes in the trilogy. Buy this book - it's a treasure!
★★★★★
An essential book for every Original Series fan!,
posted August 9, 2013 By Gerald Gurian
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
"These Are The Voyages" will be considered the ultimate reference work on TOS - a treasured and indispensable centerpiece in the libraries of Star Trek fans worldwide, to be enjoyed time and again. It is the most significant written history ever produced on the making of Star Trek: The Original Series - the most successful television series ever produced!
Writer Marc Cushman (co-creator of the story for the TNG episode "Sarek") was given unprecedented and total access by Gene Roddenberry and Bob Justman in the '80s to the entire TOS production archive (filled with memos on story development, production reports, script writing, casting, budget, etc.) and encouraged to write these books which will without question be regarded as the definitive work on TOS, and an indispensable element in every Star Trek enthusiast's personal library.
In addition to performing an exhaustive amount of research within the vast Original Series archive, now housed in the UCLA Performing Arts Special Collections library, Cushman has conducted interviews with many actors that appeared in TOS as well as many members of the production team that worked behind the cameras; quite a number of which were never approached previously for their recollections or interviewed to such great extent as they were for "These Are The Voyages". Truly, the groundwork for this spectacular biography of The Original Series has spanned a 20+ year timeframe - bringing this three volume set to the public has been a lifelong ambition of the author - and this work will never be equaled in terms of its comprehensiveness or importance to the franchise.
Readers will be captivated by the hundreds of new insights and anecdotes from both the historical records and the first hand accounts of the people that made this beloved series. A particularly, fascinating disclosure regards the true Neilsen ratings and the popularity of the TOS episodes as they were first broadcast; which was much stronger than modern day mythology has led us to believe. The author of "These Are The Voyages" licensed the complete set of Neilsen reports for all Original Series episodes and they are presented - for the first time - in this work for the public to appreciate.
The '60s Star Trek series is arguably the most successful television show of all time - spawning a franchise that has witnessed 4 subsequent television series and 12 major motion pictures to date. The mythos of Star Trek is unshakably woven into the fabric of modern day society, and iconic phrases such as "beam me up" or "set phasers on stun" are instantly recognized around the globe. Tens of millions have been inspired by The Original Series and credit it with triggering a generation of technological advancement that followed its initial release. Given the incredibly daunting task of chronicling the making of this exceptional television show in a manner that does it justice, Cushman and co-author Susan Osborn have succeeded spectacularly!
The novelesque style of writing throughout "These Are The Voyages" makes for a captivating and highly enjoyable read; literally transporting the reader onto the Desilu soundstage 47 years ago or into the Star Trek offices and boardrooms to feel as if they were a witness to the making of every, now-so-familiar episode. The intensity of the research performed and the wealth of perceptive insights on the underlying social commentaries that Gene Roddenberry insisted on designing into the episodes - something that makes TOS so dramatically stand out in comparison to virtually all other series of its day or afterwards - will be applauded by Star Trek fans and researchers for decades!
Part of the great success of Star Trek: The Original Series can be attributed to the coming together of an extraordinary team of exceptionally talented individuals - from the superlative performances of the actors in front of the cameras to the brilliance of folks like Roddenberry, John D. F. Black, Gene Coon and Dorothy Fontana in scriptwriting; the genius of Matt Jefferies in Production Design, Bill Theiss in Costume Design, and Wah Chang in Prop Design ... the list goes on and on. Cushman and Osborn have brought an equal level of talent and dedication to the creation of this work.
★★★★★
Super-detailed TOS history!,
posted August 9, 2013 By Ari Decherd
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I really enjoyed reading this! A great look behind the scenes with a terrific level of detail--the book covers every episode of the first season from the writing (and rewriting) to the filming to the editing and special effects and the network/audience/cultural response. Very easy to find yourself marathon reading through each chapter. I'm looking forward to the next two books!
★★★★★
Time portal to TOS,
posted August 8, 2013 By Suzy
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Wow! This book took me back and put me in the production offices and sound stages of the original Star Trek being written and produced. I was a fly on the wall with every page. No other book has gone into this detail or succeeded to take me back to that space or time. It is so thoroughly researched, Spock would be jealous!
Finally history never knew about the tv series!,
posted December 1, 2013 By Michael D. Heintz (Seattle, WA USA)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
In depth, thorough! New stuff, never read. Great rare pics! Amazing history and info. detailed well above and beyond other books before.
★★★★★
For Real Fans!,
posted November 23, 2013 By Stephen W. Gordon (West Valley CIty, Utah United States)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Great for the real fan. Goes into deep detail. On some scripts it gives a daily, blow by blow story of how the plot came about.
★★★★★
Wow! Fantastic book...well organized...a must have!!,
posted November 19, 2013By Alan (LaVergne, TN, United States)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Just when you think that there is nothing new to be learned about Star Trek...Surprise! This book is a wonderful read and a treasure trove for Trekkies! Lots of good information about television production back in the day. I can't wait for the follow ups for Season Two and Season Three as well!
★★★★★
Great Read, wonderful Insight....,
posted November 14, 2013 By Victor
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Got the book and It's fab... The wealth of information Gene Roddenberry and his crew retained during the filming is incredible... It is amazing that Marc Cushman was able to befriend Gene and obtain the documents to developed the true behind the scenes of Trek Original Series... Cannot wait for the Next two Installments.
★★★★★
FIVE STARS: It doesn't get any better than this!,
posted November 10, 2013 By AlwaysReading "Lane" (California)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
It doesn't get any better than this. It's a years-in-the-making book -- detailed (but not boringly so), well researched, well-sourced (quotes by the episode directors, Star Trek cast, guest actors, the scriptwriters, producers, etc.), and it is written in a style that is intelligent and entertaining. It's fun 'pick-me-up' reading and a fantastic behind-the-scenes look into the making of the first season episodes of the original series. This book and "Inside Star Trek: The Real Story" by Herbert Solow and Robert Justman will be the best two books about the original series that a Star Trek fan will ever want to read. Here's hoping that a promised Season Two book (based on the inner pages, it seems like there will be one) is published soon. Highly recommend.
★★★★★
Well Researched, Highly Readable - FANTASTIC!,
posted November 9, 2013 By A. Holland
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Not since Stephen E. Whitfield's "Making of Star Trek" have a read a book so thorough on the creation of the original Star Trek series. And thorough in different ways - it is a tremendous effort and a great work. I highly recommend this for anyone who wants to understand the nuts, bolts, and creative choices made for TOS.
★★★★★
One of the best books ever written about a TV show,
posted November 3, 2013 By Lee Goldberg (Los Angeles, CA USA)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
After nearly fifty years, I thought there wasn't anything more to be said, or any more books that could possibly be mined, from the original Star Trek. Hasn't that show been talked about, and examined to death, down to every last detail?
You'd think so. But then along came These Are The Voyages: Season One by Marc Cushman and it may be the best book yet about the production of the series and one of the best books ever written about any TV show. It's a shame the book is presented as yet another fan-written curio for the diehard trekker...because it's a must-read for students of television, and aspiring TV writers, regardless of whether they watched, or liked, Star Trek.
These Are The Voyages is an exhaustively detailed look at the writing and nuts-and-bolts production of every single episode, from the first, failed pilot onward. Everything in the book, like a TV series, starts with the scripts...and Cushman walks us through every draft and every change, whether they were prompted by creative issues, budgetary concerns, production issues, or network notes.
The author relies on extensive interviews with the show's surviving writers, producers, directors, and actors (and archival interviews with those who have passed away) and never-before-released memos, budgets, shooting schedules, and other internal documents. Best of all, Cushman manages to remain, with only a few slips, remarkably objective and scholarly about his subject, leaving the book refreshingly free of the kind of cringe-inducing, fannish drool that usually typifies books about "cult" shows and Star Trek in particular.
These Are the Voyages is a treasure trove of information and a fascinating look at how a TV show is written and produced...and all of the forces that shape it. I'm eagerly looking forward to the next two volumes.
★★★★★
Beam This Up,
posted October 30, 2013 By Mark Twain (Virginia, USA)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
This is a MUST read for Star Trek fans, It's also a great look at the early days of television on the west coast. Marc is a terrific author who has really done his research. I personally have some ties to some of the people mentioned in this book and find it very insightful. This is a great read!
★★★★★
great reading!,
posted October 28, 2013 By Joseph H Hoch JR - See all my reviews
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
A "must have" for any Star Trek fan. Marc Cushman sure did his research! Can't wait to read next two books.
★★★★★
What a revelation!,
posted October 21, 2013 By Kevin Black
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Blazing through the galaxy of Star Trek reference books comes the new gold standard. These Are the Voyages: TOS Season One by Marc Cushman is massive tome that looks like a textbook. Here it is by the numbers: 541 oversize pages of text, original interviews with 65 people important to the first season of Star Trek, including Gene Rodenberry, Robert Justman, Dorothy Fontana, James Doohan, and Grace Lee Whitney, an 11-page bibliography of books, newspaper & magazine articles, and a 15-page index of quotations. All this, and it only covers Season One!
All the secondary research is supplementary to the real heart of this book: Cushman gained access to the original series archives, safeguarded through the years by Justman and Roddenberry, and now in the custody of the UCLA Performing Arts Library. These include endless production memos and letters between writers, producers, and technical craftspeople and consultants which reveal the real story of Star Trek as it evolved on the fly from early 1964 to mid 1967. This is the kind of book that's only possible as a labor of love, 26 years in the making (Cushman wrote the treatment for the third-season Next Generation episode "Sarek," and his interviews with Rodenberry in contemplation of this writing date back to 1982 and 1990).
A work this dense may sound intimidating. Amazingly, it's compulsively readable. The 100 pages or so describing Roddenberry's background, the development of Star Trek, and the struggles to cast the show, film two pilots, and achieve a first season order read like a page-turning potboiler, informed on every page by Cushman's deep knowledge of and infectious enthusiasm for television history.
Nor does the book lose pace when it dives, one at a time, into the making of Star Trek's 29 first season episodes. Here Cushman spices things up by placing the episodes in historical context with cultural tidbits about other shows on television, songs on the radio, and moments in history. He does not forbear to offer his own careful, informative critical appraisal of each episode. The value these comments bring do not depend on the unassailability of his judgment--I disagree that episode 1.17, "Shore Leave," belongs in "the stratosphere of TOS's very best" (I think it's the worst first season episode)--but Cushman's description of its theme still caused me to reevaluate and increase my appreciation: "Dreams and nightmares sleep side by side, so be careful what you think about while on a world where wishes do come true." (Page 366.)
To read this book is to constantly learn new tidbits about and explode myths regarding favorite episodes. His interviews about the filming with guest stars both prominent and obscure add color. Did you know that episode 1.13, "The Conscience of the King," started out as a Holocaust story, with Kodos as a "Hitlerian" figure who "almost conquered the Earth?" Or that the writing staff, who hated the name Klingon, asked Gene Coon, producer and writer of episode 1.27, "Errand of Mercy," what planet Klingons came from, and he laughed and said "Kling?" Cushman also publishes for the first time the Neilson ratings for each episode, showing that Star Trek was much more popular coming out of the gate than we have always been led to believe.
While the tidbits are fun, the greatest value of These Are the Voyages is in peeling back the curtain on the creative process. How does a show as original as Star Trek get made? What makes it difficult? What were the real contributions of the people behind the scenes? Why did the staff have so much trouble with storied science fiction writers? (Cushman also includes a list of storylines that underwent development, but were never completed or produced.)
What I found most fascinating was to watch the hand of Roddenberry himself, whose reputation has suffered somewhat following questions about the quality of his contributions to The Next Generation. Cushman gives us the letters, memos and facts necessary to fully appraise his contribution as Star Trek's creator, best friend and undeniable animating spirit, but also its worst enemy at times when his combative personality strained ties with network executives, outside writers, and even his own staff. Yet when you see his mark on especially the first ten episodes, you see him repeatedly acting to make the show better, often dramatically so, no matter the personal cost. Even after Roddenberry took a step back midseason, the staff couldn't help but continue to follow his example. In Cushman's words: "As proven again and again by the documents preserved in the series' files stored at UCLA, the Star Trek creative staff was obsessively driven to make every script - every episode - as good as they could possibly be, within the limits, of time, budget and censorship." (Page 254.)
Regarding the production of These Are the Voyages itself, there are flaws in the copy editing, which only make me want to volunteer my time to help make volumes two and three the best they can be. With a book this good, the only serious criticism I can make is that it is too short. I want more of everything. More production memos! More interviews! More, bigger photographs, and in color! Hundreds more pages! This is work that could just keep going. If the universe is kind, Cushman's achievement will provide an inspiration to others.
★★★★★
top drawer,
posted October 14, 2013 By Charlie Schmidt
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
This is the best writing on Star Trek TOS ever. It is absolutely fascinating to learn of the behind the scenes production issues, script drafting and revisions, personality conflicts, killer deadline schedules. This book is worth every penny and is MUST HAVE for any person who loves TOS. Mr. Cushman, you can put me down for Volumes 2 and 3. Wow, wow, and wow.
★★★★★
I FEEL I AM THERE ALL OVER AGAIN!!!,
posted October 13, 2013 By Leslie Parrish (Seattle)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
As one of the guest stars on the original Star Trek series, (I was the Goddess in “Who Mourns for Adonais”) I’ve been thrilled and amazed reading this brilliant, detailed reconstruction of the creation of this ground-breaking series!
I feel I am there all over again ― on the Desilu lot with the visionary Gene Roddenberry and his associates ― and the great stars of TOS, who became dear friends.
Marc Cushman’s research, which I know took six years of intensive work, takes us behind-the-scenes to see what went into this series ― information than even those of us who were there never imagined!
This is the book that everyone who loves Star Trek, with its awesome insights into the future ― inventions which are present in our lives today! ― will love!!! It sweeps us up in the massive effort it took to create this unique series so filled with vision, hope, brilliance ― and longevity!
Marc Cushman deserves credit and thanks from all who read this spectacular and authoritative work!!!
★★★★★
This is The Book on Star Trek TOS,
posted September 23, 2013 By kevin vasconcelos
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I have been a fan of the show since it first aired and after reading all of the books related to the series production of this and all that came after. I would have to say this was the most satisfying of all. I thought the Herb Solow and Bob Justman book was great and put me back in the 60's mindset and helping to set the record straight-well this will be a great addition for any fan of the series. Producing a television show like Star Trek at that time was an almost impossible feat. Reading this book shows what it took to make television/cultural history.I cannot wait unit TOS Season 2 is released.
★★★★★
Truth, Myths and Spin Are All Revealed,
posted September 21, 2013 By B. W. Bordelon "Bryan" (Kenner, Louisiana United States)
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I am an original 1966 NBC broadcast Trekker who was 12 in its premiere and I have read everything published on the history of this iconic show, and while books some seemed to put you there in its creation, none has given me the feeling of fully understanding its birth. What this show did in 1966-69 was truly ground-breaking. Creative from the ground up, Star Trek boldly went where no other series has ever gone before. I cannot wait till the last two issues are published. This, along with the original series music soundtracks re-engineered and released on cd is Trek-Nirvana!
★★★★★
It is about time!,
posted September 11, 2013 By Dennis L (Evergreen Park, IL)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
It is more than just "about time" It is way past time that somebody finally gave us the entire story on this break-through series. What is even more fantastic is the detailed bibliography where one can find additional info on the series. It is too bad that the author missed one of the most important articles written about Star Trek, namely the one that was in the February, 1968 issue of Analog entitled "To Make A Star Trek". Now, I am anticipating next volume.
★★★★★
I didn't want to put it down!,
posted September 9, 2013 By Mark Thomas Passmore (St. Petersburg, FL USA)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Quite possibly the most informative book I've ever read on the original Star Trek series. Yet it has an easy style that makes one feel you were there as the events proceed. I can't wait for the next two volumes.
★★★★★
Thoroughly engaging as a Trek history read,
posted September 6, 2013 By PiperDE
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
As someone who is interested in the early history of Star Trek as a television series, Marc Cushman's book is thoroughly engaging. As a read, I find it most comparable to Inside Star Trek: The Real Story (by Herbert F. Solow and Robert H. Justman) which was 458 pages and covers a lot of "I was there" details. This book is 600 pages, weighs 2.6 pounds and there is two more coming. The amount of brand new, as well as well known information compiled from things that occurred almost 50 years ago can, at times feel overwhelming if you want to absorb every detail on every page. A lot of it is from research of original documents at UCLA. It's comprehensive and it shows. Then he adds in interviews that he did personally over the last 20 years from the main cast, directors, producers, extras and it seems anyone involved in the show. Cushman also goes on to reference a library of other biographies, autobiographies and vast stores of written knowledge. Another thing that really sets this book apart from others is a seemingly endless collection of behind the scenes photographs provided by Gerald Gurian as well as others from personal collections. This is not a book that you can sit down and read in a day. It is also a book you can pick up again and again as a reference for every episode of the first season when they were still trying to figure out how to put a difficult and expensive show on the air. I have watched my TOS blu-rays several times, but reading this adds to the experience by pointing out the extras, one episode actors, who they were, how they were cast, why they left, and information about them that had been unknown to me about their involvement before, during and after the show. He breaks down the cost of each episode, the writer, who did the re-writing, production issues, and touches on those great personal stories at every turn. It's like a fascinating college text book written by a professor you would want to keep talking to and follow down the hall even after class is over. It's entertaining to read and keeps you coming back for more early, sometimes obscure (the best kind) Trek knowledge. And there is a very complete easy to use reference at the end. As I mentioned before; there are two more of these coming that will each contain several more pages of 60's early Star Trek history. Favorite quote so far: "if the ring goes, Kelley goes."
★★★★★
Must read for TOS enthusiasts,
posted August 27, 2013 By Bret Lonsway
Amazon Verified Purchase This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
As a companion to the immortal "The Making of Star Trek" (which, by the way, NEEDS to be reissued as a high quality hardcover!), this is the definitive source on the creation, production and airing of the first season of the original Star Trek series and how it changed television forever. The saga of how ex-pilot/cop Gene Roddenberry and team convinced Lucy and Desi Arnaz to back their effort at a high-quality, adult science fiction series different from anything ever done is extraordinary and relevant to today's fragmented media landscape. It is also so good to see producer Gene Coon getting the credit he is due for really shepherding the continuity and "canon" of the Trek universe!
As Captain Kirk once said, "Risk is our business".
★★★★★
Boldly going where no behind-the-scenes books has gone before...,
posted August 25, 2013 By Christopher E.
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
A very impressive undertaking - One of the most detailed evaluations of the filming of a television series that I have seen. There have been many books discussing the filming of Star Trek, but never to this detail. With the release of long buried background material, this series has the potential to be the ultimate bible of Star Trek production. There are interviews with cast and crew, and a lot of information I never knew about the production. Great stuff.
Hard to believe this 600+ page book focuses on just one season of the original series, but it is well worth the read. Mark Cushman and Susan Osborn have their facts together and know how to make it interesting for the non-fan. For the fan, it is an absolute must. I look forward to getting the next volume covering Season 2.
★★★★★
A Must Have!,
posted August 25, 2013 By Eric Comptis
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
These are the Voyages is a must have for anyone interested in how and why this series was created. How did Gene develop the story, How was it presented to the networks, How was the director and writers picked. How was the cast picked and what were their original thoughts about the series. All these questions are answered and alot more.
This is a great book for Trekers and anyone interested in TV history. I loved it!
★★★★★
This Is Paradise,
posted August 23, 2013 By Scott (Edinburgh, Scotland United Kingdom)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
An astounding triumph for Marc Cushman. This is easily the best book on the original (and best) incarnation of Star Trek. Each episode of season one is given a detailed account of its production which includes fascinating memos and exchanges between the writers, producers, directors and actors. There is also an assessment about the strengths and weaknesses of each story. Cushman's judgement is pretty sound and I can't wait for volumes 2 and 3.
★★★★★
WOW! Best Trek Book - EVER!,
posted August 19, 2013 By Rick A
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Have you ever wished you were 'a fly on the wall' during the creation and making of the original Star Trek? Well, consider author Marc Cushman your genie and his book your wish granted.
There have been tombs of material written on the subject of Trek. From 'The Making of.. to 'The Real Story,' but NONE have captured the 'lightning in the bottle' like 'These Are The Voyages.' Every one of The original seven have put pen to paper and added their voice to the legend that is Trek, but they are coming from an actor's point of view. Those books are great reads, but they fail in comparison to what, I feel, is this 'tour de force' by author Marc Cushman. Not only does his book take you deeper than any other book but, as you read this page-turner, you'll feel like you're right there as the decisions are being made.
I was blown away by the huge amount of newly released information that you can only find in this book. New interviews with people in front of and behind the camera, memos, ratings and detailed drill downs on each and every episode of season one.
This book is a Trekkie's/Trekker's dream!
Finally, one of the most iconic shows in TV history has the first chapter in what will become an iconic trilogy of books.
All I can say is -- start making room on your bookshelf because two more volumes are on the way!
★★★★★
The Book I Have Always Wanted,
posted August 18, 2013 By LSpil (Missouri, United States)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I have hundreds of books devoted to the series and this has already become the most important one.
I have always believed that the Roddenberry papers at UCLA would make the basis for a significant contribution to the study of the show. Mr. Cushman's extensive original interviews and secondary research obviously added a great deal to the book, but his analysis of the memos and script drafts are what set this volume in its own class. Short of reading every memo and draft myself (maybe someday...), this book is the only means of determining how each episode moved from imagination to final cut, and who contributed what in each case. To illustrate the evolution of each show, and of the series itself, Cushman has incorporated original interviews and other quotations from critical (and often underrepresented) contributors to the show. Besides the crucial interviews with Gene Roddenberry, D.C. Fontana, and Bob Justman, Cushman quotes interviews with Steven Carabatsos, Gene Coon and many more. No examination of the birth of Star Trek could be complete without the participation of associate producer and script editor John D.F. Black, and Cushman has included detailed and newly shared recollections from Black and his wife Mary, who also worked on the series. Of course, the episodes speak for themselves and their artistic impact doesn't depend on understanding the means of their creation, but once a viewer decides to look at the next level--why the episodes say what they say--this work becomes a critical part of that discussion.
The book is all the more impressive for what it is not. Cushman includes all the dates, numbers, and dollar amounts that are required, but never sacrifices the narrative to those figures. Each episode is a story of production, and the details only help make the story more vivid. He is, as Dr. McCoy might phrase it, a writer, not an accountant. As a result, the book serves in two ways. I have used it as a reference source for individual questions, but it was also an absolute page-turner, which I read straight through. The refreshing thing about the book is how even-handed it is. When primary sources and participant interviews are used, such accounts can easily become hagiographies for or screeds against individuals. I would be shocked if any of the participants or their families could find any point in the book that was less than totally fair and supported. Cushman is also scrupulous about making his opinions clearly distinct from the research. This kind of analysis doesn't preclude opinion; on the contrary, it adds to the discussion. But he never blurs the line between what he has learned and what he thinks, and as a reader, I appreciate that care very much.
★★★★★
The Real Story of Star Trek,
posted August 17, 2013 By Thomas Jensen (Fairfield, CA, US) - See all my reviews
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I've known of some of Gene Roddenberry's credits, but not in the detail the author supplies on almost any fact known about the man. The first chapter alone is exceedingly interesting. I really enjoyed reading about his relationship with Erle Stanley Gardner for example. This book has captured the overall feel of the business, with the development of the networks, the working of television at the time and how Roddenberry found his place in it. Mr. Cushman's opening chapter on the man is revealing and extensive. The opening chapter is one where the curious can get up to speed on the man's life and how it started in an entertaining manner. The personal comments from the actors and those involved are priceless.
The book is quite revealing; I can't believe I'll get to read two more books on each season. Frankly, I'm not surprised that this book is good, but it's just so darn readable that I'm actually finding a new found love for the material. I have all of the books pertaining to the original show and I've found this one provides information I never knew about the series.
You get to read the memos from Gene Roddenberry, Bob Justman, et. all and there are new quotes from actors and writers who were there. It really does take you back to the time when it was all coming together and the amount of creativity involved in the undertaking.
Did you know Gene Roddenberry held studio screenings of episodes to potential writers for the show? Do you know why the Vulcan mind meld was created? The level of detail is impressive. I'd doubt that any other television show could be documented as this one has been here.
The interplay between the people who came together to create this unique and special series is great reading. Any student of television should read this book. Every episode has 20 pages of interesting tales that were never told. Comments from the studio mailbag are included after each episode chapter. Even the Neilson ratings are included. That's a first anywhere. Star Trek a failed show because of the ratings? The facts will surprise on just how well watched the original Star Trek was during its original broadcast run.
I'm feeling lucky to have this book. It's the first book since those from the 90's by the various people associated with the show, that has anything approaching new information that I'd want to know. And this book is physically a large book. I thank Jacobs/Brown for that, too.
I'm so happy this undertaking is not just by a professional who's in the business, but from a fan of Star Trek. A truly special volume for fans of the show.
★★★★★
OMG, Star Trek was NOT a network failure!,
posted August 16, 2013 By Scott Mcintyre "ssosmcin" (Long Island, NY)
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I've had this book for 6 hours and I've finally put it down, but I'm nowhere near done reading. I thought I'd read and heard it all, but Mr. Cushman has truly done an amazing job giving us the real "Real Story" by focusing primarily on production and network documentation. He explodes myths that have dogged the series for decades. The information in the book is simply astounding. I'm learning so much new information and some of it is shocking. Like the ratings.
According to the information unearthed here, Star Trek was NOT a ratings failure when it first aired. In fact, the premiere was HUGE; the first episode alone captured 47% of the viewing public! It remained in the top 40 throughout it's first season and often won it's time slot. It easily beat many shows always believed more successful, such as Batman, The Fugitive, Lost in Space and others (it's immediate contemporary - The Time Tunnel - was 20 positions lower than Trek). Why it was considered a candidate for cancellation isn't touched upon until the second volume, but my guess is that it was because the series was a ridiculously expensive series for the cash strapped Desilu studios to produce and they were in way over their heads. So the whole "Star Trek was a flop" thing was BS. It may have lost viewers later, but during its freshman season, it was indeed doing well.
Of course, no Trek book is perfect and I did notice a couple of minor errors: observations about music between City on the Edge of Forever and Operation Annihilate were swapped for example (thanks to the LaLa Land Complete Series Soundtrack Box set we know what episodes had what composed for them). But for the most part, this is an exhaustive reference. I'll probably come back and add more to this as I read one, but I know my rating won't change.
Fantastic, essential book for fans and TV historians!
You don't think you'll lean anything new? Think again.
★★★★★
Fantastic- at long last,
posted August 16, 2013 By paustin Amazon Verified Purchase
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
This book has been a long time coming. A great book based on years of research and interviews and more importantly based on the archive given to the UCLA Performing Arts Library by Gene Roddenerry & Robert Justman shortly after the series ended. A true snapshot in time unaltered by failing memories. Papers written during the blood, sweet and tears of the making of the shows themselves. Filled with fantastic and rare behind the scenes photographs. I cannot wait until the next volumes come out. If you love Star Trek and are fascinated with behind the scenes tales of these beloved episodes "the classic 79" then this is for you...you owe it to yourself to pick this up. You will not regret it.
★★★★★
Fabulous,
posted August 13, 2013 By Howard A. Jones "Howard A. Jones"
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
A fantastic look behind-the-scenes of my favorite show, with all the details I never knew I wanted to learn about how the series was filmed, created, scored, and written. The insights into how and why various choices were made is eye-opening. For instance, in the script and even in the props for "A Taste of Armageddon" it was clear that Anan 7 was using some kind of instrument to alter his voice when he contacts the Enterprise, but because of the way the director shot the scene Anan 7 seems like a fantastic mimic.
Other reviewers have already said it -- I can't wait for the next volume. And I will read the third, as well, although a detailed analysis of why the third season was so bad is apt to be even more depressing than the season itself.
★★★★★
It's a Treasure!,
posted August 12, 2013 By Mariam True
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
If you think you know everything about Star Trek, TOS, think again! "These Are the Voyages" is the definitive book on the making of the original series. The author, Marc Cushman, provides stunningly-detailed descriptions of all elements of production for each episode (in the order they were filmed) with many great behind-the-scenes photos. Significantly, the author also includes the Nielsen ratings for each episode proving that Star Trek won its time slot week after week. The book not only provides information about series production but also gives the reader insights into the making of television in the 1960s. I thoroughly enjoyed reading about Gene Roddenberry's writing career, the involvement of Desilu Productions (gotta love Lucy), the designing of the show, and the two pilots. I can't wait for the next two volumes in the trilogy. Buy this book - it's a treasure!
★★★★★
An essential book for every Original Series fan!,
posted August 9, 2013 By Gerald Gurian
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
"These Are The Voyages" will be considered the ultimate reference work on TOS - a treasured and indispensable centerpiece in the libraries of Star Trek fans worldwide, to be enjoyed time and again. It is the most significant written history ever produced on the making of Star Trek: The Original Series - the most successful television series ever produced!
Writer Marc Cushman (co-creator of the story for the TNG episode "Sarek") was given unprecedented and total access by Gene Roddenberry and Bob Justman in the '80s to the entire TOS production archive (filled with memos on story development, production reports, script writing, casting, budget, etc.) and encouraged to write these books which will without question be regarded as the definitive work on TOS, and an indispensable element in every Star Trek enthusiast's personal library.
In addition to performing an exhaustive amount of research within the vast Original Series archive, now housed in the UCLA Performing Arts Special Collections library, Cushman has conducted interviews with many actors that appeared in TOS as well as many members of the production team that worked behind the cameras; quite a number of which were never approached previously for their recollections or interviewed to such great extent as they were for "These Are The Voyages". Truly, the groundwork for this spectacular biography of The Original Series has spanned a 20+ year timeframe - bringing this three volume set to the public has been a lifelong ambition of the author - and this work will never be equaled in terms of its comprehensiveness or importance to the franchise.
Readers will be captivated by the hundreds of new insights and anecdotes from both the historical records and the first hand accounts of the people that made this beloved series. A particularly, fascinating disclosure regards the true Neilsen ratings and the popularity of the TOS episodes as they were first broadcast; which was much stronger than modern day mythology has led us to believe. The author of "These Are The Voyages" licensed the complete set of Neilsen reports for all Original Series episodes and they are presented - for the first time - in this work for the public to appreciate.
The '60s Star Trek series is arguably the most successful television show of all time - spawning a franchise that has witnessed 4 subsequent television series and 12 major motion pictures to date. The mythos of Star Trek is unshakably woven into the fabric of modern day society, and iconic phrases such as "beam me up" or "set phasers on stun" are instantly recognized around the globe. Tens of millions have been inspired by The Original Series and credit it with triggering a generation of technological advancement that followed its initial release. Given the incredibly daunting task of chronicling the making of this exceptional television show in a manner that does it justice, Cushman and co-author Susan Osborn have succeeded spectacularly!
The novelesque style of writing throughout "These Are The Voyages" makes for a captivating and highly enjoyable read; literally transporting the reader onto the Desilu soundstage 47 years ago or into the Star Trek offices and boardrooms to feel as if they were a witness to the making of every, now-so-familiar episode. The intensity of the research performed and the wealth of perceptive insights on the underlying social commentaries that Gene Roddenberry insisted on designing into the episodes - something that makes TOS so dramatically stand out in comparison to virtually all other series of its day or afterwards - will be applauded by Star Trek fans and researchers for decades!
Part of the great success of Star Trek: The Original Series can be attributed to the coming together of an extraordinary team of exceptionally talented individuals - from the superlative performances of the actors in front of the cameras to the brilliance of folks like Roddenberry, John D. F. Black, Gene Coon and Dorothy Fontana in scriptwriting; the genius of Matt Jefferies in Production Design, Bill Theiss in Costume Design, and Wah Chang in Prop Design ... the list goes on and on. Cushman and Osborn have brought an equal level of talent and dedication to the creation of this work.
★★★★★
Super-detailed TOS history!,
posted August 9, 2013 By Ari Decherd
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
I really enjoyed reading this! A great look behind the scenes with a terrific level of detail--the book covers every episode of the first season from the writing (and rewriting) to the filming to the editing and special effects and the network/audience/cultural response. Very easy to find yourself marathon reading through each chapter. I'm looking forward to the next two books!
★★★★★
Time portal to TOS,
posted August 8, 2013 By Suzy
This review is from: These are the Voyages: TOS, Season 1 (Hardcover)
Wow! This book took me back and put me in the production offices and sound stages of the original Star Trek being written and produced. I was a fly on the wall with every page. No other book has gone into this detail or succeeded to take me back to that space or time. It is so thoroughly researched, Spock would be jealous!